5 wins & 26 nominations
Primetime Emmy Awards
2026 Winner Primetime Emmy
Outstanding Supporting Actress in a Limited or Anthology Series or Movie
DTF St. Louis
2020 Nominee Primetime Emmy
Outstanding Comedy Series
Dead to Me
Shared with: Liz Feldman · Will Ferrell · Adam McKay · Jessica Elbaum · Christina Applegate · Christie Smith
2020 Nominee Primetime Emmy
Outstanding Lead Actress in a Comedy Series
Dead to Me
For playing: “Judy Hale”.
2013 Nominee Primetime Emmy
Outstanding Guest Actress in a Drama Series
Mad Men
For playing “Sylvia Rosen”.
Satellite Awards
2021 Nominee Satellite Award
Best Actress in a Series, Comedy or Musical
Dead to Me
Gotham Awards
2005 Nominee Gotham Independent Film Award
Best Ensemble Performance
Brokeback Mountain
Shared with: Heath Ledger · Jake Gyllenhaal · Michelle Williams · Anne Hathaway · Randy Quaid · Anna Faris
Film Independent Spirit Awards
2013 Nominee Independent Spirit Award
Best Female Lead
Return
MTV Movie + TV Awards
2019 Nominee MTV Movie + TV Award
Most Frightened Performance
The Curse of La Llorona
Prism Awards
2013 Winner Prism Award
Performance in a Feature Film
Return
Actor Awards
2021 Nominee Actor
Outstanding Performance by an Ensemble in a Comedy Series
Dead to Me
Shared with: Christina Applegate · Max Jenkins · James Marsden · Sam McCarthy · Natalie Morales · ·
2021 Nominee Actor
Outstanding Performance by a Female Actor in a Comedy Series
Dead to Me
2006 Nominee Actor
Outstanding Performance by a Cast in a Motion Picture
Brokeback Mountain
Shared with: Anna Faris · Jake Gyllenhaal · Anne Hathaway · Heath Ledger · Randy Quaid · Michelle Williams
TV Land Awards
2009 Winner Icon Award
ER
Shared with: Angela Bassett · Ellen Crawford · Anthony Edwards · Yvette Freeman · Alex Kingston · Lily Mariye
Online Film & Television Association
2023 Nominee OFTA Television Award
Best Actress in a Comedy Series
Dead to Me
2020 Nominee OFTA Television Award
Best Actress in a Comedy Series
Dead to Me
2013 Nominee OFTA Television Award
Best Guest Actress in a Drama Series
Mad Men
2008 Nominee OFTA Television Award
Best Supporting Actress in a Drama Series
ER
2000 Nominee OFTA Television Award
Best Actress in a New Comedy Series
Freaks and Geeks
Behind the Voice Actors Awards
2016 Nominee BTVA Television Voice Acting Award
Best Vocal Ensemble in a Television Series
Gravity Falls
Shared with: Jason Ritter · Kristen Schaal · Alex Hirsch · J.K. Simmons · Jessica DiCicco · Keith Ferguson
2015 Nominee BTVA Television Voice Acting Award
Best Female Vocal Performance in a Television Series in a Supporting Role – Comedy/Musical
Regular Show
As the voice of “C.J.”.
2015 Nominee BTVA Television Voice Acting Award
Best Vocal Ensemble in a Television Series – Comedy/Musical
Gravity Falls
Shared with: Jason Ritter · Kristen Schaal · Alex Hirsch · Niki Yang · Carl Faruolo · John DiMaggio
2014 Nominee BTVA Television Voice Acting Award
Best Female Vocal Performance in a Television Series in a Supporting Role – Comedy/Musical
Gravity Falls
As the voice of “Wendy”.
2013 Nominee BTVA Television Voice Acting Award
Best Female Lead Vocal Performance in a Television Series – Comedy/Musical
Gravity Falls
As the voice of “Wendy”.
International Online Cinema Awards (INOCA)
2013 Nominee INOCA TV
Best Guest Actress in a Drama or Comedy Series
Mad Men
The Stinkers Bad Movie Awards
2002 Nominee Stinker Award
Worst On-Screen Group
Scooby-Doo
Shared with: Matthew Lillard · Sarah Michelle Gellar · Freddie Prinze Jr.
Gold Derby Awards
2026 Nominee Gold Derby TV Award
Limited/Movie Supporting Actress
DTF St. Louis
2006 Nominee Gold Derby Film Award
Ensemble Cast
Brokeback Mountain
Shared with: Anna Faris · Jake Gyllenhaal · Anne Hathaway · Heath Ledger · Randy Quaid · Michelle Williams
Dorian TV Awards
2020 Nominee Dorian Award
Best TV Performance – Actress
Dead to Me
Astra Television Awards
2026 Winner Astra TV Award
Best Supporting Actress in a Limited Series or TV Movie
DTF St. Louis
Gotham TV Awards
2026 Nominee Gotham TV Award
Outstanding Supporting Performance in a Limited or Anthology Series
DTF St. Louis
